William Jeffrey and Mary Lyall
 Family History and Bi-Centennial

JEFFREY, Honourable Andrew

JEFFREY, Honourable Andrew

Male 1800 - 1863  (63 years)

Personal Information    |    Media    |    Notes    |    Sources    |    All    |    PDF

  • Name JEFFREY, Andrew 
    Prefix Honourable 
    Born 17 Feb 1800  Foulden, Scotland Find all individuals with events at this location  [1, 2, 3, 4
    Christened 16 Mar 1800  Foulden, Scotland Find all individuals with events at this location  [3
    Gender Male 
    _FSFTID L2NW-D6D 
    _UID 4009496C7D92E645AA1B7FE4F9C2EADDE2E2 
    _UID 48C3B6390E9A43B5A58EBC8837C29F8B340C 
    Died 27 Jul 1863  Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  [1
    Buried 1863 & 1870  Cobourg Union Cemetery, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  [5
    Person ID I8  William & Mary Jeffrey
    Last Modified 5 Sep 2022 

    Father JEFFREY, William (I),   b. Abt 1775, Berwickshire, Scotland Find all individuals with events at this location 
    Mother LYALL, Mary Edna,   b. 4 May 1774, Sunnyside, Chirnside, Berwickshire, UK Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 26 May 1857, Peterborough, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 83 years) 
    Married Abt 1797 
    _UID 584527CD2F95A847AB0F6C979CE543BC815D 
    Family ID F16  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

    Family 1 HALL, Janet,   b. 21 May 1808, Clackmannan, Scotland Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 10 Oct 1851, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 43 years) 
    Married 18 Feb 1828  Cobourg, Ontario, Canada Find all individuals with events at this location  [1
    _UID CF1F079768E4D9428158A4024B6B11C801EF 
    Children 
     1. JEFFREY, Jane,   b. 17 Dec 1828, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 13 May 1892, St Catherines, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 63 years)
     2. JEFFREY, William,   b. 22 Mar 1831, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 21 May 1908, Stratford, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 77 years)
     3. JEFFREY, Mary,   b. 4 Feb 1833, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 11 Jun 1902, St Catherines, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 69 years)
     4. JEFFREY, James,   b. 15 Apr 1835, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 5 Feb 1872, Mecklenberg County, Virginia, USA Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 36 years)
     5. JEFFREY, Andrew S.,   b. 6 Apr 1837, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 11 Apr 1910, Raleigh, North Carolina Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 73 years)
     6. JEFFREY, Francis,   b. 16 Mar 1839, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 11 Nov 1910, Toronto Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 71 years)
     7. JEFFREY, Isabella,   b. 1 Feb 1842, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 6 Jun 1889, St Catherines, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 47 years)
     8. JEFFREY, John,   b. 14 Feb 1844, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 4 Mar 1890, Owen Sound, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 46 years)
     9. JEFFREY, George,   b. 16 Oct 1846, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 3 Feb 1850, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 3 years)
    Family ID F4  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

    Family 2 MOSCRIP, Agnes,   b. 19 Jan 1819, Upper Canada Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 9 Jan 1876, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 56 years) 
    Married 4 May 1853  Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  [1, 6
    _UID 57D8A37BF385BD489590DD3B552EAB3F74A6 
    Notes 
    • MARRIAGE: Married by the Rev. John Cassie
      (from Port Hope Guide - May 3, 1853) [7]
    Children 
     1. JEFFREY, Donald McLeod,   b. 28 Sep 1854, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 24 Jan 1876, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 21 years)
     2. JEFFREY, Janet,   b. 3 Aug 1856, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 8 Aug 1941, Buffalo, New York State, USA Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 85 years)
     3. JEFFREY, Henry,   b. 12 Jan 1860, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 26 Jun 1952, Pasadena, Los Angeles, California Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 92 years)
     4. JEFFREY, Alexander Laing,   b. 11 Nov 1862, Cobourg, Ontario Find all individuals with events at this location,   d. 11 Jul 1938, Oakland, Alameda, California Find all individuals with events at this location  (Age 75 years)
    Family ID F6  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

  • Photos









  • Notes 
    • Doubt about birthplace:
      -Swinton, according to his death announcement in the Cobourg Sentinel Aug 1, 1863 (see Misc Stuff Library, Item 4, page 15)
      -Foulden, according to the John Jeffrey family bible (See John Jeffrey Library, Item 2, page 2)
      -Foulden - tombstone Cobourg Union Cemetery
      -Chirnside, Berwickshire, according to William Jeffrey (II) Library, Item 3.
      These places are all close to each other. It appears he felt he was from Foulden

      Joined the Presbyterian Church in Scotland at age 17 (See William Jeffrey (II) Library Item 3)

      Arrived in Canada with Lyall and Hall families in 1820 (see passenger lists for steamboat from Quebec to Montreal Aug 13, 1820 in Andrew Jeffrey Library Item 12, and John Cowan's email to Jim Jeffrey Nov 22, 2018). Also see "Emigrated to Canada at age 20" (=1820) in William Jeffrey (II) Library Item 3.

      May have met future wife, Janet Hall at age 12, while coming to Canada, unless the families knew each other in Scotland and decided to emigrate together.

      His signature can be seen in Janet (Jessie) Jeffrey's visitor book (see Janet Jeffrey Library Item 4, page 4).

      Businesses
      Hardware merchant. Though active in the Board of Trade in 1845 (see below) the first mention of his business (Hardware Store) is Jan 1, 1848 - Page 128 of "Early Cobourg" by P. Clemo (see below). Then the Cobourg Star April 11 1849, Page 2 Col 4, reports that "we understand that Andrew Jeffrey, Esq, one of our well known and highly respected Hardware merchants, is about building a large two storey shop on his present site. Location is 19 King Street West, at First Street, Lot 1 of Block B in Lot 16 Conc A - See Library Item 25. Then his own announcement in the same newspaper next week (Apr 18, Page 3 Col 4) that he had moved to the "store formerly occupied by Thomas Eyre, Esq, next door to the Albion Hotel. Being about to erect new buildings on the old site" he was having a sale. See Library Item 29. (Albion Hotel was at 44 KIng St E - Eyre's store was Conger's store in the sketch on P 37 of R Mikel's book "Cobourg The Spirit of the Place," accroding to R Mikel in email to John Cowan Feb 9, 2020.)

      Foundry property owner. By marrying the widow of John McLenhan, Andrew became owner of the McLenhahn Foundry on Division Street at Spencer (See Library/Andrew Jeffrey/Item 26h) Though he is described as owner of the (renamed?) Cobourg Foundry, business records show that James Davidson operated Cobourg Foundry and paid rent to Andrew Jeffrey.

      Shareholder in the Grand Trunk Railway

      Built the third sawmill on Rice Lake with Thomas Scott in 1851, competing with the Fortune Mill. This new sawmill was next door to Mr Fortune's residence (Ref "P.55 "Gore's Landing and Rice Lake Plains" 1986 by Norma Martin, Catherine Milne and Donna S McGills, published by Heritage Gores Landing, 1986, Haynes Printing, Cobourg)

      Operated a Cobourg school in 1832 "on the north side of King St at the corner of D'Arcy" (Page 139 "Cobourg 1798-1948"). (John Cowan speculates that this was on the west side of D'Arcy Street - see Homes, below) Also R. Mikel reported to John Cowan Oct 28, 2019 that a history Schools in Cobourg says his school was on the NW corner where the Rosevear house now stands.

      Cobourg & Peterborough Railway chartered in Dec 1852 ....... see https://www.cobourghistory.ca/histories/harwood-station-museum/65-cobourg-peterborough-railway-part-1-the-railway

      Community Service
      Dec 2, 1836 Andrew Jeffrey and two others were appointed by a town meeting to petition 'both houses of the legislature' to amalgamate Amherst and Cobourg and incorporate the combined Town of Cobourg, separate from the rest of Hamilton Township. Their petiton worked as on March 4, 1837 the legislature passed "The Act to Establish A Police in the Town of Cobourg, and to Define the Limits of said Town." The Act established bylaws for the town and fines for transgressors, as well as grannting the power to tax and invest in infrastructure.(ref p71-81 of "Early Cobourg" by Percy Climo, published around 1985, in the possession of John Cowan.)

      June 1837 elected as a member of the first Police Board governing Cobourg (before town council existed). He served one year. (To be qualified for this role persons needed to have an "assessed" property value for taxes of at least 60 pounds. - see weblink in Library/Misc Stuff/Item 21)

      Dec 6-19, 1837 he first served as a private in the First Northumberland Militia hastily formed to put down the Mackenzie Rebellion. He probably saw no action as they would have arrived at the scene of battle in Toronto too late for the action - Mackenzie had already fled. However he also served Nov 13, 1838 to May 7 1839 (see Library/Andrew Jeffrey/Items 34 and Jim Jeffrey email to John Cowan Jan 17, 2020).

      Elected as President of the Committee of Management of the new Board of Trade Sept 15, 1845 - as reported in the Cobourg Star Sept 17, (see "Early Cobourg" Page 120)

      Justice of the Peace. In the July 18 1849 edition of the Cobourg Star, Andrew Jeffrey and Thomas Eyre (see also Library Item 29) were "convicting justices" for 3 cases of selling liquor without a license (fines of 5-7 pounds each) and 2 cases of assault (fines 3-10 shillings each).

      Founding Elder and Trustee of St Andrews Presbyterian Church in Cobourg. Aug 14, 1833 "Andrew Jeffrey et al Trustees" for the Presbyterian Church bought a half acre lot from Henry Ruttan (see https://www.cobourghistory.ca/biographies/henry-ruttan) (Lot 19 Conc A, Block A, lot 7) according to Land Titles records. Appreciation for his service to the Church seen in letter from the Church (Library/Andrew Jeffrey/Item 35b).

      Trustee for the town's collection of funds to support the establishment of Queen's University in Kingston, hoping it will provide Presbyterian-oriented training in general and training of badly needed ministers.(1840) (Library/Items 8 & 9)

      Chairman of the Cobourg and Rice Lake Plank Road and Ferry Company. He is listed as Chairman publishing the third annual report of the company as it was completing its plank and gravel road to Gores Landing. See Library/Misc Stuff/Item 22-B. He may also have been a shareholder, though we found no evidence of such.

      Mayor of Cobourg in 1852, also Councillor in 1851 (ref Cobourg 1798-1948" Page 253by Edwin Guitllet 1948) (In 1852 town decided to build the Cobourg & Peterborough Railway, crossing Rice Lake.)

      President of the Board of Trustees of the Northumberland and Durham Savings Bank (ref Library Item 31) 1852 to his death.

      Appointed one of five Commissioners of the Cobourg Town Trust 1859 until his death. He was Chairman from 1859. See letter of appreciation upon his death Library/Andrew Jeffrey/Item 35a.

      In 1848 he was the Reform candidate for the Legislative Assembly. In 1859 he went to the Provincial Reform Convention in Toronto, where he was Chairman of the Committee on Resolutions. (ref John Graham's Jan 1998 presentation to the Lakeshore Genealogical Society - Library\William Campbell Jeffrey Materials\Item 5)

      Elected to the Legislative Council of the Province of Canada in 1860 (until his death) representing the Newcastle Division.

      Homes
      Assessment records reviewed by William Campbell show that Andrew lived somewhere on Lot 15 Concession A in Hamilton Township (Cobourg) from at least 1826 to 1838. (Library\William Campbell Jeffrey Materials\Item 10 Census records) Also Settlement map (Library/Misc Stuff/Item 26)shows him as being on an easterly portion of Lot 15.

      The Architectural Conservancy of Ontario (cobourghistory.ca/architecture) recorded that Andrew Jeffrey built a house at 272 University Ave West in Cobourg in the 1830s. It is shown on Sandford Flemings 1846 Map (Library/Andrew Jeffrey Item 26b) (See Library Item 28) He probably lived there until 1844. When it was built, University Ave was called Seminary. Also, its front entrance faced directly to William Street. In modern times a lot has been separated off on William Street so the house no longer has access to William, instead University. It is very close to the first Church property for which he was a Trustee in 1833. Andrew's house was demolished in 1893 according to Cobourg World May 17, 1893 (see email from R Mikel to John Cowan Oct 28, 2019)

      He built a new house in 1844 at the corner of King and Ontario Street (See Library Item 24). It was a large property for a house, occupying lots 12, 13, 25 and 26 of Block I in Lot 19 Concesssion A. Robert Mikel reported Oct 19, 2019 that the Polson's rented the house at some stage after the Jeffreys moved out (still in the 19th century). This house was used as West End Public School after 1928 (see Library/Misc Stuff/Item 21 page 1). It was taken down in the 1960s.(ref Robert Mikel - see Library Doucment Index for Item 27). The school's grounds were described in 1937 as "large spacious grounds are one of the beauty spots of Cobourg." (see Library/Misc Stuff/Item 21) A park was on the site until 1995 when the Public Library was built there.

      He bought 4 acres from Abraham Crouter on Sept 10, 1839, in the west part of Lot Pk Lot A, in Lot 18 Conc B (Land Titles Record for Lot 18, in Northumberland County Archives, page 3, Instr 5649.) This property faced Victoria St, close to what became the Grand Trunk Railway (Library/Andrew Jeffrey/Item 26f). He was probably first user of this land since Crouter bought a 60 A chunk in 1836 and a 57 A chunk in 1837. (A lot contains 200 A.) He and his wife sold 9/100 acre to GTR on July 2, 1856 (Registry Lot 18 page 11, Instr C63). Robert Mikel speculated with John Cowan (Oct 19, 2019) that the land was probably used to provide food for the family, since no industrial facilities were known on the property until modern times.

      1861 Census (Library/Misc Stuff/Item 28 P1) show his mother-in-law (Jane Moscrip) living with him, as well as two unkowns: Harriet, age 19, and I. Thompson Age 17.

      His will made his eldest son (William) executor and heir. His assets at death seem minimal (need to source this).

      In Oct 1866 William Jeffrey was discharging(?) 6 mortgages on Parts 12, 13, 25 and 26 in Part ?? of Lot 18 Conc A - the land that Andrew's house stood on. Or was he granting mortgages on sale - its unclear from the incomplete land title records in the Northumberland Archives. Two of the mortgages were to a person by the name of Daintry. GS Daintry was Mayor of Cobourg in 1864 and 1865.

      Misc facts:
      Land Titles records for Lot 18 show that Andrew Jeffrey loaned money via a mortgage on a half acre of land to James Burnett (location unknown) on Oct 16, 1846. Instr 8256.

      It was reported by Jessie Belle Jeffrey Greig to John Cowan that Andrew entrusted his chequebook with a fellow peer of the church so that the contractor building the new church in 1862 could be paid while Andrew travelled on government business. His bank account was cleaned out and the contractor was not paid. Was this a stress that led to Andrew's early death within a year? Or is this the family story to account for the financial distress commonplace in the town as recession hit (Speculation by R Mikel Oct 19, 2019).

      His Obit reports that "the places of business in town were closed from noon to 2 o'clock, in token of respect to the departed" Obit also speak in glowing terms of his upright character. (See Library/Misc Stuff/Item 22-C)

      BAPTISM: From the Foulden Parish Register - Andrew, lawful son to William Jeffrey and Mary Lyall, born Feb 17th, baptised March 16th 1800, before these witnesses viz: Andrew Jeffrey, Peter Jeffrey

  • Sources 
    1. [S3] John Jeffrey Bible, Mary Sutherland, Library/John Jeffrey/2-John Jeffrey Bible. (Reliability: 2).

    2. [S9] Cemsearch.com, cemsearch volunteers, (Volunteer survey of south-central Ontario cemeteries), ID#30271.
      Used for month and day of birth only.

      Year of Andrew Jeffrey's death was shown as 1853 by cemsearch, which is wrong. So John Cowan notified cemsearch Jan 13, 2015

    3. [S23] Andrew Jeffrey, (Extract of Old Parochial Records for Foulden Parish) (Reliability: 3), 23 Nov 2017.
      Library/Andrew Jeffrey/11-Baptism Pointer

    4. [S114] Foulden Parish Births and Baptisms, Andrew, lawfull son to William Jeffrey and Mary Lyall, Born February 17th 1800.

    5. [S4] Cobourg Union Cemetery, Lot 26&7-B (Reliability: 3).
      West end, south of the back road, facing the river. Cemetery records (Library/Misc Stuff/Item 1a) show that Andrew McLenham (sic) bought this plot with 12 lots in August 1870, probably at the time graves were moved from the original St Andrews Church site.

    6. [S120] Port Hope Guide Marriage Notice, Marriage Notice; May 1853.

    7. [S3] John Jeffrey Bible, Mary Sutherland, Library/John Jeffrey/2-John Jeffrey Bible.